| VOLUSIA EXPOSED.COM |
|
| Since the local State Attorney does not maintain a "Brady List" of "Brady Cops", VolusiaExposed.Com will compile it's own "Brady Bunch" list. What is a "Brady List? What are "Brady Cops"? And why is this information important? Read below for the answers to those questions. |
August 11, 2023 |
The below information is believed to be accurate at time of posting, if this is not the situation, please contact us at the below email address. Please be prepared to forward documents that support your position.
Feedback@VolusiaExposed.com
| Officer Tabitha Martin Veracity questioned by court Supportive documents Judge Will's Order to Suppress Evidence Chief Chitwood's letter to Judge Will David Beauprez's arrest report Currently employed with DBPD |
Sgt. Scott Lee Veracity questioned by court Supportive documents Judge Will's Order to Suppress Evidence Chief Chitwood's letter to Judge Will David Beauprez's arrest report Currently employed with DBPD |
Deputy Brodie Hughes Veracity questioned by Sheriff Supportive documents Deputy Hughes' demotion letter Media article - Hughes' demotion Currently employed with VCSO |
|
Deputy Mike Odgers Veracity questioned by Sheriff Sworn testimony not consistent with facts Supportive documents Deputy Odgers' demotion letter Currently employed with VCSO |
Ofc. Robert Tameris Veracity questioned by court Convicted Felon / Sexual Offender Supportive documents Tameris' plea to have sex with minors Employment Terminated |
Deputy Heather Post Veracity questioned by Sheriff Sworn testimony not consistent with facts VolusiaExposed has some concern whether this former deputy actually had veracity issues. We invite you to read our below article - in which we express our concerns - and our final rationale for including Deputy Heather Post on our Brady list IN THE DEFENSE OF DEPUTY POST Resigned |
|
Deputy Shane Duggan Veracity questioned by Sheriff Sworn testimony not consistent with facts Supportive documents Deputy Duggan's Internal Investigation Employment Terminated |
Deputy Travis Deane Veracity questioned by Sheriff Sworn testimony not consistent with facts Supportive documents Deputy Deane's Internal Investigation - Part 1 Deputy Deane's Internal Investigation - Part 2 Employment Terminated |
Lt. Brian Nardiello Exceeded his law enforcement authority regarding the arrest of Karl Rommel Supportive documents VCSO Internal Affairs Report County Council Agenda item Employment Terminated |
| Deputy Kory Gaeta Veracity questioned by Sheriff Supportive documents VCSO Investigative Report Employment Terminated |
Deputy Michael Sawicki Resigned under investigation VCSO Investigative Report VolusiaExposed offers the opinion that the VCSO failed to investigate the allegations against Deputy Sawicki within Florida laws / mandates. VolusiaExposed Web Article Resigned (REHIRED 9/2015) |
Deputy Andrew Oliver Resigned under investigation VCSO Investigative Report 1 VCSO Investigative Report 2 VolusiaExposed Web Article Resigned |
| Deputy Keith Baughman Veracity questioned by Sheriff Supportive documents VCSO Investigative Report VolusiaExposed Article Additional Misconduct IA15-18 Keith Baughman - January 2016 Currently Employed |
Deputy Peter Taraborelli Professionalism questioned by the Sheriff Supportive documents VCSO Investigative Report VolusiaExposed Article Currently Employed |
Officer Matthew Booth False Statements Excessive Use Of Force Supportive documents DBPD Investigative Report VolusiaExposed Article Employment Terminated |
| Officer Justin Ranum False Statements Supportive documents DBPD Investigative Report VolusiaExposed Article Resigned While Under Investigation |
Officer Charles Geiger Falsifying Signatures On Traffic Citations Supportive documents EPD Investigative Report VolusiaExposed Article One Day Suspension - Currently (5-28-14) Still Employed |
Sgt. Jeffrey Wingard Failing To Accurately Report Incident Supportive documents VCSO Investigative Report VolusiaExposed Article Currently (6-6-14) Still Employed |
|
Deputy Greg Nunziato Altering A Search Warrant Sworn testimony by Deputy Nunziato Supportive documents VolusiaExposed.Com Article Currently employed with FCSO |
Ofc. Joshua Marlett Criminal, Dishonest, or Other Sustained Misconduct Via IA Investigation Supportive documents VolusiaExposed.Com Article Currently employed with Beach Patrol |
Ofc. Chris Richardson Falsifying Jail Reports VolusiaExposed.Com Article Employment Terminated |
|
Ofc. Sarah Martin Untruthfulness As Determined By 2010 Internal DBPD Investigation Ofc. Martin was terminated for untruthfulness in 2010 - but rehired after a union settlement agreement. In 2014, Ofc. Martin was arrested regarding a DV incident - she submitted her resignation while under an internal affairs review Email Confirmation Of 2010 Investigative Findings Ofc. Martin's 2014 Resignation Letter |
Deputy Joel Hernandez Excessive Use Of Force As Determined by Sheriff & CJSTC Supportive documents Deputy Hernandez's IA Report Deputy Hernandez's Written Reprimand Deputy Hernandez's CJSTC Letter Of Guidance Excessive Use Of Force Is A Police Officer Moral Character Violation, As defined within Florida Administrative Code 11B-27.0011 Currently (9-23-2014) employed with VCSO |
Acting Police Chief Donna Lavallee Veracity questioned by City Supportive documents Non-Disclosure & Settlement Agreement VolusiaExposed.Com article Currently (Nov. 2014) employed with NSB PD |
|
Sgt. Shon McGuire Derogatory Remarks Concerning Race, Sex, Religion, Age or National Origin Supportive documents VCSO Internal Affairs Report 14-019 McGuire's CJSTC 78 Form Florida Officer Moral Character Standards FAC 11B-27.0011 Currently (11-6-14) Still Employed Other Incidents Related To Deputy Shon McGuire VCSO Internal Affairs Report 14-015 VCSO Internal Affairs Report 12-003 |
Deputy Breck Sanders Sustained Un-Truthful Statements Supportive documents Internal Affairs Investigation IA-14-024 Currently (2-6-2015) Still Employed Other Incidents Related To Deputy Breck Sanders VCSO Internal Affairs IA -14-028 VolusiaExposed.Com's Article Regarding Deputy Sanders |
Deputy Ralph Cerulli Refusal To Follow Lawful Orders Regarding Random Drug Testing Supportive documents Internal Affairs Investigation IA-14-026 NO LONGER EMPLOYED AT VCSO VolusiaExposed.Com's Article Regarding Deputy Cerulli |
|
Ofc. Larry Jones Falsification of Report Groping Female Prisoner Supportive documents Investigative Report CURRENTLY (Feb. 18, 2015) STILL EMPLOYED Pending Termination |
Deputy Terry Laloo EXCESSIVE USE OF FORCE WITH INJURIES Supportive documents Internal Affairs Investigation IA-14-029 DEMOTED - Later Resigned Our Article Regarding The Laloo Incident |
Sgt. Jim Davis False Statement - Inappropriate Conduct While On Duty Supportive documents Ormond Beach PD's Internal Investigation Findings CJSTC 61 Form Filed To FDLE Sustaining Moral Character Violations Employment Terminated Supportive Media Article With Additional Allegations Molestation Of 14 Year Old Girl |
|
Deputy James Matthewman 4th Amendment Issues Supportive documents Internal Affairs Investigation IA-15-002 Suspended Currently (May 1, 2015) Still Employed |
Sgt. Frank Geremia Ordering Arrest WithOUT Probable Cause Supportive documents Internal Affairs Investigation IA-15-001 VolusiaExposed's Article Demoted (Recommended) (June 1, 2015) Still Employed |
ASA J. Ryan Will Mischaracterization Of Evidence Supportive documents Supreme Court Reprimand Fl. Bar Ruling Fl. Supreme Court Reprimand |
|
Officer Isadore Wood False Report (Head Count Report) Supportive documents Internal Affairs Investigation Letter Of Suspension 5 Day Suspension |
Sergeant Joseph Sellix Improper Conduct With Public Supportive documents DBPD Internal Affairs Investigation LARGE FILE (4MB) - Allow Time To Download Employment Terminated With DBPD REHIRED IN APRIL 2017 (see below Daytona Beach News Journal Article) April 18, 2017 DBNJ Article RESIGNED - after additinal allegations of inappropriate comments April 11, 2018 article |
Officer Bobbie Jo Solomon Positive Drug Test - Cocaine Supportive documents DBPD Internal Investigation Employment Terminated With DBPD |
|
Lt. James Brodick Arrest Without Probable Cause Supportive documents DBPD Internal Investigation Currently (Sept 2016) Employed With DBPD |
Ofc. Michelle Smith False Statements / Use Of Deadly Force Supportive documents VolusiaExposed Article Resigned |
Deputy Michael Agostinis Un-Truthfulness Supportive documents VCSO IA Investigative Report Resigned |
|
Deputy Bryan Scott Barnett Sex Allegations Supportive documents VCSO IA Investigative Report CJSTC 61 Form Resigned |
Lt. Roxanne Morrow Sex Allegations Misuse Of Law Enforcement Databases Supportive documents Port Orange PD's IA Investigative Report CJSTC 61, 61A & 78 Forms Resigned |
Division Of Correction County Jail Sgt. Darlene Capps Entering Into A Relationship With Ex-Inmate Supportive documents VCDC IA Report & CJSTC 61, 61A Forms Resigned While Under Investigation |
|
Deputy Jayson Richardson Failing To File / Falsifying Use Of Force Report Supportive documents VCSO Internal Affairs Investigation Letter Of Reprimand Un-Related PINAC Article Regarding Deputy Richardson |
Deputy Danielle Basciano Relationship With Jail Inmate Supportive documents FCSO Internal Affairs Investigation Other Supportive Documents / Resignation Letter Resignation |
Deputy Kenneth Long Use Of Deadly Force Violation Supportive documents VCSO Internal Affairs Investigation Employment Terminated |
|
Deputy Jay Hawman Inappropriate Contact With Female Inmates Supportive documents VCSO Internal Affairs Investigation Employment Terminated |
Captain Charlie Brown Violating Constitutional Rights Supportive documents VCSO Internal Affairs Investigation Employment Terminated |
Matthew Snyder Racial Texts Supportive documents EPD Internal Affairs Investigation Employment Terminated (resignation) |
|
William Wetherell Racial Texts Supportive documents EPD Internal Affairs Investigation Employment Terminated (resignation) |
Ofc. Nicholas Aitchison On Duty Sexual Misconduct Supportive documents VCSO Arrest Report Regarding Aitchison DBPD Internal Affairs Investigation LARGE FILE - Victim's Name Was Redacted By VolusiaExposed Aitchison relinquishes Law Enforcement Certification Employment Terminated (resignation) |
Deputy Andrew Jenkins Excessive Use Of Force Supportive VolusiaExposed.Com Article With Documents & Videos Employment Terminated |
|
Ofc. Beau Estrada Sex On Duty / False Statements Supportive VolusiaExposed.Com Article With Documents & Videos |
Division Of Corrections Ofc. Joseph Coleman Sexual Misconduct Supportive VolusiaExposed.Com Article |
The Evidence Room Audit Reveals Evidence Problems Supportive VolusiaExposed.Com Article |
|
Medical Examiner Documents Several Deficiencies, Then Resigns Supportive VolusiaExposed.Com Article |
Sgt. John Bray Unbecoming Conduct Moral Character Violation Supportive VolusiaExposed.Com Article Retired During Investigation |
Deputy John Freshcorn Un-truthfulness Unbecoming Conduct Moral Character Violation Supportive VolusiaExposed.Com Article Employment Terminated |
|
Ofc. Joey Mulero Excessive Use Of Force False Arrest DeLand PD Internal Affairs Report CJSTC 61 Report For Excessive Force & False Arrest Rehire Based On Arbitrator's Ruling Employment Terminated (REHIRED 3/2021) |
Lt. Joseph Swetz Interference With Investigation Misuse Of Law Enforcement Database POPD Termination Letter VolusiaExposed.Com's January 27, 2019 Article Employment Terminated |
Sgt. Steven Braddock Allegations of Forgery State Attorney's Brady Letter VolusiaExposed.Com's January 27, 2019 Article Retired While Under Investigation |
|
Deputy Brandon Bivone Falsifying Report Internal Affairs Report IA-19-006 Still Employed - Employee Performance Notice Issued |
ASA Richard Hill Impeding Judicial System Internal Affairs Report IA-19-004 Still Employed Verbal Counseling |
ASA Jake Westbrook Impeding Judicial System Internal Affairs Report IA-19-004 Still Employed Verbal Counseling |
|
Deputy Robert Campbell Impeding Judicial System Internal Affairs Report IA-19-004 Still Employed - 240 hr Suspension |
Officer Darnell Gatling Perjury POPD - Internal Affairs Report Employment Terminated |
Officer Austin Lefleur False Report VolusiaExposed Article With Supportive Documents Employment Terminated |
|
Officer Leslie Goins False Report VolusiaExposed Article With Supportive Documents Employment Terminated |
Officer Paul Turner False Report DeLand PD IA Report Employment Terminated |
Sgt. William Warmington Misconduct VolusiaExposed Article, With Supportive Documentation Demoted To Police Officer |
|
Deputy Julio Rodriguez Several Act Of Misconduct VolusiaExposed Article, With Supportive Documentation Resignation While Under Investigation |
Falsification Of FDLE / CJSTC Files VolusiaExposed Article, With Supportive Documentation An OPINIONATED Conclusion By This Publication |
Sgt. Jacob Kraker Unlawful Use Of Deadly Force VCSO Internal Affairs Report Sgt. Kraker's Termination Letter Employment Terminated |
|
Deputy Tyler Lawrence Untruthfulness VCSO Internal Affairs Report & Supportive Docs Employment Terminated |
Deputy Phillip Donaldson Untruthfulness VCSO Internal Affairs Report & Supportive Docs Resignation |
Lieutenant Kyle Bainbridge Sexual Harassment VCSO Internal Affairs Report CJSTC Separation Forms Resignation WHILE UNDER INVESTIGATION (click here to read resignation letter) |
|
Deputy Austin Rosa Felony Domestic Violence VCSO Press Release & Arrest report Resignation WHILE UNDER INVESTIGATION (click here to read VCSO internal investigation ) |
Deputy Ricky Wright Neglect Of Duty / Child Sex Abuse Resignation WHILE UNDER INVESTIGATION (click here to read VCSO internal investigation ) |
Deputy Sean McRae Sexual Harassment Resignation WHILE UNDER INVESTIGATION (click here to read VolusiaExposed article) |
|
Deputy Enmanuel Pena Sexual Harassment Resignation WHILE UNDER INVESTIGATION (click here to read VolusiaExposed article) |
Captain Frank Williams Sexually Explicit Statements Terminated (click here to read VolusiaExposed article) |
|
|
|
|
|
Earlier this year (2012), VolusiaExposed.Com became aware that many State
Attorney offices within Florida, and across the nation maintain what is commonly
referred to as a "Brady List". This list is development and maintained by each
particular State Attorney office, in order to effectively comply with the
mandates of a 1963 U.S. Supreme Court decision Brady
vs. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963).
In Brady, the court ruled that the prosecutor has the responsibility to give the defendant any and all exculpatory evidence (evidence that tends to prove the suspect not guilty). This exculpatory evidence includes, past histories of police officers, whereas, the veracity of those officers has come into question. In short, if a police officer makes an arrest, the defense has the right to know, if that arresting officer has moral character skeletons hiding in his / her career closet. A past history of providing false or misleading statements, or excessive use of force would be reportable under Brady.
When VolusiaExposed.Com became aware that two other Florida investigative websites had successfully secured and posted these "Brady Lists" from the 10th and 17th Judicial Circuit's State Attorney's offices, we decided that our readers would enjoy a review of the "Brady List" from the Seventh Judicial Circuit.
10th Judicial Circuit's State Attorney Brady
list
17th Judicial Circuit's State Attorney Brady list
VolusiaExposed.Com made a public record request to the the Office of R.J.
Larizza, the Seventh Judicial Circuit's State Attorney, for a copy of his "Brady
List". Unfortunately, we were advised in the below January 13, 2012 response
that the Seventh Judicial Circuit does not maintain a "Brady List".
VolusiaExposed.Com initial January 9, 2012 request for a copy of
the 7th SA's Brady list.
State Attorney January 13, 2012 response to VX
VolusiaExposed.Com January 16, 2012 follow up request for public records
State Attorney January 23, 2012 response to VX
In our opinion, a Brady list is an essential tool in ensuring the
fairness of any community's criminal justice system. For whatever reasons, State
Attorney R.J. Larizza has opted not to compile such a list. Therefore, absent an
official Brady List from our local State Attorney, VolusiaExposed.Com has
started our "Brady Bunch" list.
We invite the public to submit possible "Brady Cops" to us for review and possible inclusion to our "Brady Bunch" list. However, we shall only consider officers for inclusion, that have been deemed to be compromised in some way, by either their peers, their supervisors / departments, the courts, OR the totality of the evidence.
In Brady, the court ruled that the prosecutor has the responsibility to give the defendant any and all exculpatory evidence (evidence that tends to prove the suspect not guilty). This exculpatory evidence includes, past histories of police officers, whereas, the veracity of those officers has come into question. In short, if a police officer makes an arrest, the defense has the right to know, if that arresting officer has moral character skeletons hiding in his / her career closet. A past history of providing false or misleading statements, or excessive use of force would be reportable under Brady.
When VolusiaExposed.Com became aware that two other Florida investigative websites had successfully secured and posted these "Brady Lists" from the 10th and 17th Judicial Circuit's State Attorney's offices, we decided that our readers would enjoy a review of the "Brady List" from the Seventh Judicial Circuit.
17th Judicial Circuit's State Attorney Brady list
State Attorney January 13, 2012 response to VX
VolusiaExposed.Com January 16, 2012 follow up request for public records
State Attorney January 23, 2012 response to VX
We invite the public to submit possible "Brady Cops" to us for review and possible inclusion to our "Brady Bunch" list. However, we shall only consider officers for inclusion, that have been deemed to be compromised in some way, by either their peers, their supervisors / departments, the courts, OR the totality of the evidence.